TownHall.com

At time of statehood, Hawaiians wanted no part of race focus by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Erica Little and Todd Gaziano of the Heritage Foundation point out that at the time Hawaiian was entering the Union, Native Hawaiians were adamant about being considered in the same way that all others are. In essence, Hawaiians at the time were adamant that their race not be part of the equation:

Hawaii’s statehood referendum passed with an incredible 94.3 percent of the vote. About 95 percent of the Hawaiians who voted specifically agreed to all the terms of the admission act. Fewer than 8,000 Hawaiians voted no on either question. Because approximately 20 percent of the population in 1959 would have qualified as “native” under the definition in S.147, then at least three-fifths of that group must also have voted for statehood with no separate rights for individuals of their ancestry.[6] Though a small minority opposed statehood, at no point in the statehood debate did anyone in Congress suggest that the U.S. should treat so-called “native Hawaiians” like an Indian tribe. As the above statements demonstrate, Hawaiians’ sentiment was, in fact, quite the opposite.

The people of Hawaii had the opportunity to raise an issue regarding separate rights for native Hawaiians. Not only did they fail to do so; they went to great lengths to convey that Hawaii did not and would not divide its people by race. That was the understanding of those in Congress and Hawaii who voted to bring Hawaii into these United States. Despite the distorted history of the S.147’s supporters, many Hawaiians with aboriginal ancestry still share that understanding today. They understand that S.147 will change their state from a “microcosm of America” to an environment that pits race against race.

So what has changed Senator Akaka?  

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Death tax still lives by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades...conservatives lost their bid to attain 60 votes to repeal the unjust tax 57-41.

So far, this week in the Senate is shaking out as feared: loss on marriage amendment, loss on Death Tax...is the creation of a race-based government this afternoon pending? 

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Vote on Akaka at 12:45 by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist announced this morning that the Senate will vote on cloture on the Death Tax Repeal at 10:45 and then regardless of the outcome of that vote, will vote on the Akaka bill at 12:45.

Did conservatives muster the requisite 41 votes needed to kill race-based governing? Senate sources say it will be a razor thin margin...

In the meantime, read this entry on Red State that makes a valid point. Republicans don't deserve the majority if they let this pass. Granted, there are many outstanding conservatives in the Senate fighting this bill. But their challenge must be to sway the votes of the moderate faction of the caucus who seem intent on voting this majority right out of town. 

Categories: News, TownHall.com

White House opposes Akaka bill by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Finally, the White House has climbed down off the fence to oppose Akaka's race-based governing bill. In a June 7 letter from Assistant Attorney General William Moschella addresed to Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, the White House makes their opposition clear.

"The Administration strongly opposes passage of S. 147," reads the missive. "As the President has said, 'We must honor the great American tradition of the melting pot, which has made us one nation out of many peoples." This bill would reverse that great American tradition and divide people by their race."

The letter is in direct contradiction to Senator Daniel Akaka's claims on the Senate floor that the Administration had cleared the legislation. The letter goes on to cite e US Civil Rights Commission report that opposes the Akaka bill because it divides people by race.

Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid was carbon copied on the letter.

UPDATE: Read the uploaded letter here.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Taxpayer funded race-based governing by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

From my column today:

Our nation’s capital is echoing with alohas this week. The Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA) has flown key players in to Washington, D.C. to lobby Capitol Hill in favor of S. 147, the Native Hawaiian Government Reorganization Act.

The taxpayer-funded organization plans to hold a news conference Thursday morning on the West Lawn to tout a bill many critics say would create the first ever race-based government in the United States.

The press conference is part of OHA’s extensive lobbying strategy. Already the group has spent more than $660,000 of taxpayer funds to hire the well-connected D.C. lobby shop Patton Boggs.

OHA wants its lobbying effort to pay off when the Senate votes on S. 147 (maybe as early as Thursday evening). Opponents of the bill need 41 votes to deny cloture and therefore kill it.

Multiple Hill sources confirm that opponents of the bill (a pet project of Democratic Sen. Daniel Akaka of Hawaii) have absolutely no idea how that vote will go. This is one of those rare instances in the Senate where the outcome of a scheduled vote isn’t all but certain ahead of time. According to one Senate source, conservatives opposing Akaka may be within one vote of the requisite 41. That should encourage conservatives to keep cranking on all cylinders and apply the necessary pressure to the U.S. Senate.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Dead by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Best news of the day...

UPDATE: Texas Senator John Cornyn: "Al Zarqawi has made his last video."

UPDATE: RSC Chairman Mike Pence: "I rejoice in the death of no man, but today I'll make an exception."  

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Leave it to Ted Stevens... by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

...to provide Republican cover for Akaka's bill by taking the Senate floor to speak in defense of race-based governing.

We all know Stevens is a powerful man in the Senate -- his support has helped Akaka tremendously. 

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Alexander: Akaka bill assault on American values by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Tennessee Senator Lamar Alexander is on the Senate floor right now speaking against the Akaka bill. The bill, says Alexander, "is an assault on E Pluribus Unum." The bill "undermines our unity...it would undermine our history of being a nation based not upon race but upon common values of liberty, equal opportunity and democracy."

Exactly.

UPDATE: Akaka is on the floor defending his bill: "At the heart of it, this bill is about fairness and creating a process to achieve it."

UPDATE: Republicans are doing well to control floor time and oppose the Akaka bill. So far this afternoon Senators Alexander (who was outstanding and eloquent), Kyl, Craig, Sessions and Cornyn (on the way) are speaking against the bill. Only Byron Dorgan and Daniel Akaka have had the gall the defend the bill for the Dems.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Brownback on the fence regarding race-based governing by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Kansas Senator Sam Brownback is reportedly a fence-sitter on the pending vote to create an unconstitutional race-based government in Hawaii. So is Susan Collins...

Someone should remind Brownback that he is a conservative and a good man who reveres the constitution. People expect more of him than this.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Marriage amendment fails to garner Senate majority by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

A vote on the Federal Marriage Amendment in the Senate today failed to garner support of even a majority of the Senate today, failing 49-48.

UPDATE: From the AP:

WASHINGTON - A constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage went down to Senate defeat Wednesday, but supporters said that several new votes for the measure represent progress that gives the GOP’s base reason to vote on Election Day.

Supporters failed to get the 60 votes required for the measure to survive a test vote. Had it survived, a two-thirds majority in both houses of Congress would have been required to send an amendment to the states. It then would have had to be ratified by at least 38 state legislatures.

But they took solace in the fact that the idea received several new votes from Republican freshmen elected after the amendment received its last vote in 2004.

UPDATE: Republicans who joined Democrats in voting against the amendment included Sens. John McCain (R-AZ), John Sununu (R-NH), Olympia Snowe (R-ME), Susan Collins (R-ME), Arlen Specter (R-PA), Judd Gregg (R-NH) and Lincoln Chafee (R-RI).

Chuck Hagel (R-NE) skipped the vote. 

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Akaka bill closer to vote by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Drudge today is linking to a Washington Times piece on the Akaka bill to create a race-based government.

From the article:

Hawaii Sen. Daniel K. Akaka thinks Hawaiians should be allowed to govern themselves as Native Americans and Alaskans do, and after seven years of pushing a bill to start the process, the Senate is expected to take it up this week.

Mr. Akaka says the bill is a way to give "indigenous" Hawaiians a sense of pride and a chance for sovereignty for the first time since 1893, when Queen Liliuokalani was deposed and lands were illegally seized by U.S. Marines and a cadre of sugar-plantation businessmen.

More:

The bill calls for an Office of Native Hawaiian Relations in the Department of the Interior, and a Native Hawaiian Interagency Coordinating Group to administer programs, a commission that would certify who are indigenous Hawaiians, and provides a process of reorganization of the Native Hawaiian governing entity.

"The bill will not authorize gaming in Hawaii. The bill will not allow private lands to be taken. The bill will not create a reservation in Hawaii," Mr. Akaka said.

But, according to Senate sources, at least one Republican Senator approached the bill's supporters including Hawaiian Governor Linda Lingle to talk about the gambling issue. The supporters of the bill were asked to clarify that this would not lead to gambling in Hawaii but Lingle expressly declined that request.

A vote on the unconstitutional Native Hawaiian Government Reorganization Act is expected tomorrow evening.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Repealing the Death Tax would be double good by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

If Senate conservatives overcome the odds this Thursday and invoke cloture on the Death Tax Repeal bill not only will the unjust and excessively punitive death tax be on the fast track to repeal, but a vote on the race-based creation of a new Native Hawaiian government will be delayed.

The Senate schedule currently calls for the consideration of the Akaka bill after the consideration of Death Tax repeal. If conservatives break a Democratic filibuster against the Death Tax Repeal the Senate will be forced to debate the Death Tax for an extended period of time -- leaving opponents of race-based governing more time to garner the necessary votes to kill the Akaka bill.

As reported below, opponents of Akaka are close...but I think need more time.

Word on the Hill is that some of those opponents will organize a press conference tomorrow to help rally the troops. Will it be too little too late? I hope not.

UPDATE: The presser is a go:

WASHINGTON—U.S. Sens. John Cornyn (R-Texas) and Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) will hold a press conference on Wednesday, June 7 in S-219, the Capitol, to discuss their opposition to legislation that would create a racially-separate government for native Hawaiians living across the United States, the Native Hawaiian Government Reorganization Act of 2005, S. 147.

Sens. Cornyn and Alexander will be joined by native Hawaiians who are in Washington to express their opposition to the legislation, and the Chairman of the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Gerald A. Reynolds. WHAT: U.S. Sens. John Cornyn and Lamar Alexander hold press conference with native Hawaiians and Chairman of U.S. Civil Rights Commission to oppose Native Hawaiians Bill

WHEN: Wednesday, June 7 2:00 p.m.

WHERE: Room S-219, the Capitol
Categories: News, TownHall.com

Dems preparing to dump Jefferson by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

The House Democratic Steering Committee is meeting today to consider whether or not to strip Rep. William Jefferson of his Committee slot.

UPDATE: Newt Gingrich says it is time to strip Jefferson of his Ways and Means Committee Post: 

As someone who led the pledge in the Contract with America for members of Congress to abide by the same laws as the rest of us, I have been following the case of Rep. William Jefferson (D-La.) with growing concern. The time has come for the House leadership to make clear that, in protesting the FBI's raid on Jefferson's congressional office, they are protecting the Constitution, not protecting corruption.

Nothing would send this message with more clarity than to move this week to strip Rep. Jefferson of his position on the powerful Ways and Means Committee. Simultaneously, the House Ethics Committee should begin proceedings leading to the possible expulsion of Jefferson from Congress. The Ethics Committee also should ask the Justice Department to cooperate in this effort to protect the House from corruption, and the Justice Department should agree. Like all of us, Rep. Jefferson has the presumption of innocence, and he should be allowed to defend himself. But as a member of the U.S. House of Representatives, he should be notified by leadership that if he fails to cooperate in timely manner to House actions, the House will protect its institutional integrity from behavior unbecoming of a member and intolerable to the People's House by moving to expel Jefferson.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Outcome of Native Hawaiian vote very much in doubt by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

A Senate vote on cloture on the motion to proceed to the Native Hawaiian bill is likely to occur this Thursday. Opponents of race-based governing need 41 votes to deny cloture and therefore kill the bill.

Various hill sources confirm that opponents of the Akaka bill have absolutely no idea how that vote will resolve itself. This is one of those rare instances in the Senate where the outcome of a scheduled vote is all but certain. According to one Senate source, opponents of race-based governing may be as close as one vote shy of the requisite 41 votes. That figure should be enough to get conservatives cranking on all cylinders in order to apply the necessary pressure to the U.S. Senate.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Gingrich likes the Pence immigration plan by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Newt Gingrich gives kudos to the Mike Pence immigration reform plan in his latest Human Events column:

One positive addition to the border-security and immigration debate is Rep. Mike Pence's (R-Ind.) bill, the Border Integrity and Immigration Reform Act. This bill is as close to the right solution as I have seen. It sets up a four-step process starting with what is needed and universally agreed upon -- border security. Second, it does not provide amnesty for people in the United States illegally. It requires them to go home. Next, it sets up a work-visa program using electronic bio-metric security based on conservative market principles. After an American employer can, in good faith, show that no American worker will fill a job offer, a work-visa holder may be hired. The key feature is that, in order for people who are here illegally to get a work visa, they must go home, because work visas will only be issued outside of the United States. Fourth, once the program is set up, companies that continue to ignore the law will be sanctioned severely.

I hope the House will take a serious look at Rep. Pence's thoughtful and pragmatic approach to solving this issue.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Railroad to nowhere still lurks by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26
Once thought dead, Mississippi's Railroad to Nowhere appears to be back on track. Congress Daily AM reports that the emergency supplemental bill currently in House-Senate conference may contain funding for the CSX railroad relocation:
The final bill is expected to preserve about $5.2 billion for Community Development Block Grants -- $1 billion more than the House included. Although the exact contents were being worked out, Mississippi would stand to gain, and Barbour might still see some seed money for a complex railroad relocation and coastal development plan.
Categories: News, TownHall.com

The skunk at the party: Native Hawaiian sovereignty by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

As mentioned yesterday, the Senate this week is casting politically explosive votes. Two on items generally favored by conservatives, and one on the unconstitutional Native Hawaiian Government Reorganization Act.

The Hill reports:

The Senate will vote this week on cutting off debate on a constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriages, an issue conservatives have clamored for since the 2004 election. It will also vote to quash a potential filibuster of the estate-tax repeal, another high priority for conservatives.

But Frist has also brought a skunk to what otherwise would be a conservative garden party by also scheduling the Native Hawaiian Government Reorganization Act, sponsored by Democratic Sen. Daniel Akaka (Hawaii).

More: 

Aides to conservative senators say they are discussing ways to tie the bill up on the floor, possibly by offering anti-abortion amendments. But, nevertheless the bill has a good chance of passing, and if it does it will likely be with the support of almost every Senate Democrat and a minority of the Senate Republican Conference.

If conservative GOP senators such as Lamar Alexander (Tenn.), Jeff Sessions (Ala.), John Ensign (Nev.), Tom Coburn (Okla.) and John Cornyn (Texas) square off against the Hawaii bill, as they are expected to, it would be the second time in a month that the conservative heart of the Senate GOP conference has rebelled against a bill Frist has brought to the floor. Passage would begin to establish a trend in which bills pass the Senate floor with overwhelming Democratic support and the backing of few Republicans.

“Frist is the leader of what may be a Republican majority but isn’t a conservative majority,” said Michael Franc, vice president of government relations for the Heritage Foundation.

As we have seen, Franc is right. This is indeed a disturbing trend. 

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Sessions: end the death tax by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

Alabama Senator Jeff Sessions today has a must read Op-Ed in the Washington Post:

The list of reasons for eliminating the death tax is long. To begin with, this tax punishes thrift and saving. It tells people that it's better to spend freely during their lifetimes than to leave assets for their children and grandchildren, which will be taxed heavily by the federal government.

The death tax hits hardest at heirs of small-business owners and family farmers. In many cases, the heirs cannot afford to pay the tax and are forced to downsize, lay off employees or even sell their business or farm.

There can be no doubt that closely held family businesses that are growing and beginning to compete with the big guys are often devastated by the tax. I believe the death tax is a major factor in business consolidation and loss of competition.

This tax hurts the growth of minority-owned businesses. As the first generation of African American millionaires begins to die, many of the companies they founded will have to be sold to pay the estate taxes. For example, the tax almost forced the oldest African American-owned newspaper -- the Chicago Daily Defender -- out of business.

Also pay close attention to Andy Roth's blogging as this issue plays out on the Senate floor this week.

Categories: News, TownHall.com

Specter quotes Sullivan by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26
Senator Arlen Specter today took the Senate floor to speak against the pending Federal Marriage Amendment. To make his point, he quoted Andrew Sullivan (and others) as being in the tradition of Barry Goldwater. Specter quoted Sullivan as saying the amendment "egregiously violates states' rights and seeks to impose a uniform settlement on an entire country in perpetuity."
Categories: News, TownHall.com

What is Reid up to? by TimChapman

TownHall.com - Capitol Report - Thu, 2024-05-02 18:26

This afternoon, when the Senate gavelled in from its week long recess, Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid used a parliamentary procedure to hold up the completion of the immigration reform bill.

Given the terrible mess the Senate passed bill is in, this will not make too many conservatives unhappy.

Neverthless, Reid took advantage of the fact that the Senate bill is not in compliance with the constitutional rule that all revenue bills must originate in the House. The Senate bill contains tax revenue positions, and as such faces a "blue slip" in the House -- a process where the House denies the Senate-passed bill for the aformentioned reason.

GOP Senate leadership had hoped to fix the problem by attaching the immigration bill to a earlier passed House revenue bill and then sending it back to the House. When Senate Whip Mitch McConnell asked unanimous consent to do that today, Reid objected insisting that Democrats would want to amend that House passed bill.

McConnell pointed out that all the amendments that Dems wanted to attach to that bill could be attached to the pending Death Tax Repeal bill. 

This tactic fits in well with the idea that Reid wants to kill the immigration reform bill because he thinks Republicans will suffer in November if they fail to pass any bill. 

Categories: News, TownHall.com
Syndicate content